NYCHSFL Playoff Preview: Semifinal Edition

Six teams move one step closer to a championship. There is no room left for mistakes.

I’m a little late getting this one out. I was away this weekend, and between trying to catch up on all the playoff action and balancing everything that comes with family and everyday life, getting through every game took a little longer than expected. But the quarterfinals delivered, and now we’re down to the semifinal round.

My quarterfinal picks finished 6–2. I got Hayes, St. Anthony’s, Kellenberg, St. Joseph by the Sea, Kennedy Catholic, and St. Dominic correct. I missed on Xavier over Xaverian and St. Peter’s over Fordham Prep.

That’s playoff football. The margin for error gets smaller, the competition gets tougher, and one bad quarter can end a season.

Now it’s time for the semifinals. My approach is simple this week: give me the top seeds. But that doesn’t mean these games are guaranteed. Every team left has earned its place, and nobody is going to hand over a championship opportunity.

AAA Semifinals

Iona Prep vs. Cardinal Hayes

My Pick: Iona Prep

Cardinal Hayes earned its place in the semifinals with a hard-fought 16–10 win over Stepinac. This was a defensive battle, and Hayes found a way to make the plays that mattered. A blocked punt and a touchdown from Kymonni Valentine helped swing the game, while the Hayes defense made life difficult for Stepinac.

Give Stepinac credit as well. Nahum Pierre and the offense kept fighting, and Phillip Simms had to deal with an aggressive Stepinac defense that came away with two interceptions. But when the game was on the line, Hayes made the plays necessary to move on.

Now comes a much different challenge.

Iona Prep enters the semifinal round undefeated at 9–0, with 372 points scored and only 77 allowed. The Gaels have been one of the most complete teams in the league, and their résumé speaks for itself. Their combined margin against Monsignor Farrell, St. Anthony’s, and Cardinal Hayes is 101–9.

That is an impressive statement against the league’s best competition.

Iona players to watch

  • Jaydin Jackson, QB: Jackson is the engine of this offense. He has thrown 19 touchdown passes and completed 63.3% of his attempts. He can distribute the football, extend plays, and make defenses account for him as a runner.
  • Chase Reeves, RB: Reeves has been a major part of Iona’s offensive production, averaging approximately 122 rushing yards per game with 12 rushing touchdowns. He gives the Gaels a physical presence and keeps defenses from focusing exclusively on Jackson.
  • Trey Newton, WR: Newton has been Jackson’s most productive receiving target, averaging close to 80 receiving yards per game with 10 receiving touchdowns. He is an explosive option who can change a game quickly.

Cardinal Hayes players to watch

  • Kymonni Valentine: Valentine came through with a touchdown in the quarterfinal win and will need to be a difference-maker again.
  • Johnnye Booker: Hayes needs its playmakers to help sustain drives and take advantage of scoring opportunities.
  • London Rucker: Hayes will need a strong performance from its key contributors on both sides of the football.

The matchup: Hayes must find a way to slow down an offense that can beat you through the air and on the ground. The defense cannot allow Jackson to get comfortable, and it cannot lose control of the line of scrimmage against Reeves.

For Hayes, this is about playing disciplined football, limiting explosive plays, and making every possession count. You cannot afford to give Iona extra opportunities.

Iona has been dominant, and the Gaels have too many ways to hurt a defense. Hayes will compete, but I’m taking Iona to advance.

Monsignor Farrell vs. St. Anthony’s

My Pick: Monsignor Farrell

This is another heavyweight matchup, and it has the potential to be one of the best games of the semifinal round.

St. Anthony’s comes in after an impressive 42–27 victory over Chaminade. Xavier Bala was outstanding, finding the end zone four times, while Anthony Diieso and the rest of the Friars’ offense helped keep the pressure on Chaminade throughout the game.

Chaminade had its moments, with Anthony Trapani, Michael Genovese, and Sean Carnevale contributing, but St. Anthony’s had too much offensive firepower.

Now the Friars get Monsignor Farrell.

Farrell enters at 9–1, with wins over Xavier, Cardinal Hayes, and St. Anthony’s already on its résumé. The Lions closed the regular season with a 21–0 shutout of St. Joseph by the Sea. This is a team that knows how to win big games and has the physicality to compete with anyone in the league.

There is also a bigger story here.

Since 2021, Iona and Farrell have met twice in the CHSFL AAA Championship. Iona won 49–15 in 2021 and 42–20 in 2025. Farrell is looking to get back to the championship game and potentially earn another shot at the Gaels. But first, the Lions have to take care of St. Anthony’s.

Farrell players to watch

  • Bryce Moye, QB: Moye has thrown for 1,611 yards and accounted for nine total touchdowns. He has been on varsity since his freshman year and brings experience, arm talent, and the ability to extend plays.
  • Jayden Burch, RB: Burch averages approximately 112 rushing yards per game. His ability to run between the tackles, break through contact, and create explosive plays will be critical.
  • Braxton Moye, WR/Edge: Braxton is a physical target who averages approximately 66 receiving yards per game. He also contributes defensively as an edge player, making him an important two-way presence.

Keep an eye on the defense: Charles Costanzo has been a major difference-maker, averaging approximately 8.8 tackles per game and leading the team with 12 sacks in the latest reported statistics. If Farrell can pressure the quarterback and disrupt the timing of the St. Anthony’s offense, that could become a major advantage.

St. Anthony’s players to watch

  • Xavier Bala: Coming off a four-touchdown performance, Bala is the player Farrell must account for every time he touches the football.
  • Anthony Diieso: Diieso is another important piece of the Friars’ offensive attack.
  • Rory McDermott: McDermott will be one of the contributors St. Anthony’s needs to step up in a high-pressure semifinal.

The matchup: Farrell has to establish Burch early. If the Lions can run the football, control the clock, and keep the St. Anthony’s offense on the sideline, they can dictate the pace of this game. Moye will need to make the throws when the opportunities are there, while the defense must contain Bala and avoid giving up explosive plays.

I also want to give credit to head coach Rocco Del Priore. Farrell may not have the same player pool as some of the larger programs, but year after year, this team finds a way to compete at the highest level. That comes down to development, discipline, organization, and getting the most out of the players in the program. Del Priore has been with Farrell for 21 years and is in his fifth season as head coach. His work has helped establish a program that expects to compete for championships.

And on the other sideline, St. Anthony’s has a strong program and a talented group that is more than capable of making this difficult.

I’m taking Farrell in a physical game. The Lions have the experience and balance to get it done.

The potential championship trilogy

If Iona and Farrell both handle their semifinal assignments, we could be looking at a third meeting in the AAA championship since 2021. That’s a compelling storyline, but both teams have work to do before anybody starts talking about a rematch.

Championships aren’t won on paper. Handle the business in front of you first.

AA-I Semifinals

Kellenberg vs. Fordham Prep

My Pick: Kellenberg

Kellenberg advanced with a 23–7 win over St. Francis Prep. The game stayed competitive through three quarters, but Kellenberg eventually created separation and took control.

The offensive production from this group continues to be built around its ability to run the football. Brayden Farrelly, Brendan Barkley, Quinn Saccheri, and Doug Cristales have given the Firebirds multiple options. Coming into the regular-season finale, Saccheri, Barkley, and Cristales had combined for 1,534 rushing yards and 21 touchdowns.

That’s a difficult group to prepare for.

Fordham Prep comes into this game after a 35–25 victory over St. Peter’s. Luke McKay led the way with three touchdowns, while Vincent DiPasquale helped direct the offense. The Rams also got important defensive contributions, including a pick-six from Saladino and a forced fumble by Gilbert that was recovered by Ross.

Fordham has shown it can create momentum on both sides of the ball.

Kellenberg players to watch

  • Brayden Farrelly: A key part of the Firebirds’ offensive attack.
  • Brendan Barkley: His physical running style gives Kellenberg another option to keep the chains moving.
  • Quinn Saccheri: A productive piece of the rushing attack who can make defenses pay if they lose their assignments.

Fordham Prep players to watch

  • Luke McKay: Coming off a three-touchdown performance, McKay is a major part of the Rams’ offensive production.
  • Vincent DiPasquale: His ability to manage the offense and make plays through the air will be important.
  • Saladino: His pick-six in the quarterfinal showed the impact Fordham’s defense can have when it creates turnovers.

The matchup: Kellenberg needs to establish its ground game and avoid putting itself in obvious passing situations. Fordham has to find a way to slow down the Firebirds’ multiple rushing threats and create turnovers.

For Fordham, this game will come down to discipline and tackling. You cannot allow Kellenberg to consistently win first down and dictate the game.

I like Kellenberg’s balance and ability to control the football. Give me the Firebirds to advance.

St. Joseph by the Sea vs. Xaverian

My Pick: St. Joseph by the Sea

This is a matchup between two teams that have already shown they can handle adversity, but Sea is coming off one of the most dramatic finishes of the quarterfinal round.

The Vikings defeated St. John the Baptist 35–28 in overtime after trailing 28–14 with 9:16 remaining. Sea scored three consecutive touchdowns to force overtime and then completed the comeback.

Joseph Moran was spectacular, finishing with nine receptions for 129 yards and three receiving touchdowns. Pete Tronolone completed 13 of 25 passes for 174 yards and three passing touchdowns, while also adding a rushing touchdown and 77 rushing yards.

But here’s the concern: Sea cannot keep putting itself in these situations.

The Vikings have a chance to make history by reaching their third consecutive championship game. That’s an incredible opportunity, but the road gets tougher every week. You cannot expect to fall behind, rely on late-game heroics, and keep finding a way out. Eventually, the comeback doesn’t come.

This must have been a great atmosphere. The energy, the comeback, and the finish made it one of the most entertaining games of the weekend.

I have to give credit to the FB4 guys on Instagram for helping bring the final minutes and overtime to everyone watching from home. It’s disappointing that Sea hasn’t streamed its games this season. A program with this kind of following and this kind of opportunity should make it easier for people to watch. The FB4 guys stepped up and gave fans a chance to follow an exciting finish.

Xaverian earned its place here with a 27–21 comeback win over Xavier. Xavier had built a 21–7 lead, but Xaverian refused to go away. Richie Aiken, Jake Price, and Christian LaRocca helped lead the comeback, which included a successful onside kick and a fourth-down touchdown connection involving Spaeth.

That was a major win for Xaverian, and the Clippers deserve credit for staying in the fight.

Sea players to watch

  • Joseph Moran: Coming off a three-touchdown receiving performance, Moran is a major matchup problem.
  • Pete Tronolone: His ability to make plays with his arm and legs gives Sea an important offensive weapon.
  • Arthur McCarthy: Another key contributor who will need to help Sea execute in a demanding semifinal.

Xaverian players to watch

  • Richie Aiken: A key contributor in the comeback against Xavier.
  • Jake Price: His play will be important as Xaverian looks to sustain its momentum.
  • Christian LaRocca: Another player who helped fuel the Hawks’ quarterfinal victory.

The matchup: Sea must start faster. The Vikings cannot afford to spot Xaverian a two-touchdown lead and expect another comeback. The offense needs to be balanced, and the defense has to make Xaverian earn every yard.

Xaverian has momentum and confidence after coming back against Xavier. They know they can overcome adversity, but Sea has the offensive weapons to make this a difficult afternoon for the Hawks.

I’m taking St. Joseph by the Sea, but the Vikings need to play a complete game. The cardiac-kid act has to end if they want to keep their championship hopes alive.

AA-II Semifinals

Mount St. Michael vs. St. Dominic

My Pick: Mount St. Michael

St. Dominic made history with its 27–16 victory over Christ the King. It was the program’s first playoff win in 51 years since returning to the NYCHSFL, and that deserves recognition.

This was a significant accomplishment for the Bayhawks. Ray Minson, Anthony Branscum, Michael Ford, and Aaron Bengston were among the contributors in a win that will be remembered by the program.

There is something special about a team that can build toward a moment like this and finally get over the line. Congratulations to St. Dominic on earning that victory.

But the celebration has to be short. The next challenge is Mount St. Michael.

Mount enters this semifinal as the top seed and will be looking to use its experience and physicality to move one step closer to a championship. St. Dominic has momentum, but the Bayhawks now face a different level of competition.

St. Dominic players to watch

  • Ray Minson: A key contributor in the quarterfinal victory.
  • Anthony Branscum: His production will be important if the Bayhawks are going to keep this game competitive.
  • Michael Ford: Another player St. Dominic will need to make an impact.

The matchup: St. Dominic needs to bring the same energy and execution that carried it through the quarterfinals. The Bayhawks cannot afford mistakes or wasted possessions against a top seed.

Mount’s challenge is to avoid overlooking a team that is playing with confidence and has already made history this postseason. The Mountaineers need to establish control early and make St. Dominic play from behind.

I’m going with Mount St. Michael. St. Dominic has earned plenty of respect, but I believe the top seed advances.

Holy Cross vs. Kennedy Catholic

My Pick: Holy Cross

Kennedy Catholic put together one of the most dominant performances of the quarterfinal round, shutting out Cardinal Spellman 42–0.

The Gaels have been playing some excellent football, winning five of their last six games. During this recent run, they’ve outscored their opponents 201–20. That’s a significant turnaround and a clear indication of how well this group is playing.

Dominick Tassone, Joseph DeSocio, and Austin Lanara are among the players Kennedy will need to rely on as it looks to keep its season alive.

But now comes Holy Cross.

Kennedy has already seen what Holy Cross can do. The Knights defeated the Gaels 33–6 earlier this season, and that result cannot be ignored. Kennedy has improved since then, but the challenge is clear: the Gaels need to show they can compete with a team that has already beaten them convincingly.

Kennedy players to watch

  • Dominick Tassone: A key player for the Gaels as they look to continue their strong postseason run.
  • Joseph DeSocio: Kennedy needs its playmakers involved and producing.
  • Austin Lanara: Another important contributor who will need to step up against Holy Cross.

The matchup: Kennedy has to find a way to generate offense against a Holy Cross team that held it to just six points in their earlier meeting. The Gaels cannot afford to fall behind early, and they need to avoid the turnovers and mistakes that can swing a playoff game.

Holy Cross has the advantage of having already beaten Kennedy, but the rematch will be a test of whether Kennedy has closed the gap.

I’m taking Holy Cross to advance. Kennedy has been impressive lately, but Holy Cross has already demonstrated that it can control this matchup.

Coach X and O’s Semifinal Picks

DivisionMatchupMy Pick
AAAIona Prep vs. Cardinal HayesIona Prep
AAAMonsignor Farrell vs. St. Anthony’sMonsignor Farrell
AA-IKellenberg vs. Fordham PrepKellenberg
AA-ISt. Joseph by the Sea vs. XaverianSt. Joseph by the Sea
AA-IIMount St. Michael vs. St. DominicMount St. Michael
AA-IIHoly Cross vs. Kennedy CatholicHoly Cross

Final Thoughts

We’re at the point in the season where talent alone isn’t enough. Every team left has talent. Every team left has players who can make a difference. The teams that advance will be the ones that execute, protect the football, tackle, and stay disciplined when the pressure is at its highest.

Iona and Farrell have the potential to set up another chapter in their championship rivalry. Sea has an opportunity to make history, but it has to stop making things harder than they need to be. Kellenberg and Fordham will be a battle of execution, while the AA-II matchups give us two more opportunities to see which teams are ready for the next step.

My picks are in: all six top seeds move on.

But this is playoff football. There are no guarantees, no style points, and no tomorrow for the teams that don’t get it done.

Handle your business. Earn your next game.

— Coach X and O’s

Leave a Reply

Designed with WordPress