First things first, I was away this weekend, so I had to go through all these games yesterday, and this is why this post is coming out now. There were some rivalry games played, some history made, and of course quality playoff NYCHSFL competition this past weekend. Luckily, most of the games were available on replay so I was able to go through them.

Waiting in the wings in the ‘AAA’ are Iona Prep and Monsignor Farrell. In the ‘AA-I’, the top seeds were pushed to the brink. In the ‘AA-II’ history was made, and the Mount and Holy Cross waited and who their opponent would be.

See the scores below:

‘AAA’

  • Cardinal Hayes 16-Archbishop Stepinac 10; In the rain, on Friday night, the rivalry between the Cardinals and Stepinac would be center stage. On SageMediaSolutions at Columbia, the Battle of the Bronx was a defensive slugfest. Archbishop Stepinac would draw first blood, with James Lilly hitting a field goal with 7:13 reamining in the 1st quarter to take a 3-0 lead. The Stepinac defense would be suffocating for much of the evening, intercepting Phillip Simms off twice over the first half. Just before the half, with Booker at quarterback, the Cardinals exploded down the filed with a 30 yard run by Booker. Kenzo Jackson gashed the Crusaders on the next play for 19 yards. The half would end with a 12 yard touchdown strike from Booker to Saleh Atariwa to get on the board with 17 second left in the half. As the 3rd quarter begun, it was Simms at quarterback, and the steady running of Jackson that would guide the Hayesmen down the field. A few big plays from Simms to Atariwa, along with some key conversions by Jackson got the ball near the redzone. Kymonni Valentine would plod his way inside the 15 yard line, but the Stepinac defense would stand tall, holding the Hayesmen out of the endzone. Chace Grogan would nail the 30 yard field goal to give the Cardinals a 7 point lead with 6:37 left in the 3rd quarter. The Crusaders, with Dylan Wrona, Nahum Pierre, and Nicholas Harrison would respond immediately. On the next possession, Pierre would run for a big gain to the Cardinal’s 36 yard line. On the next play, Wrona found Harrison down the sideline for a touchdown to knot the game up at 10 a piece with about 6 minutes left in the 3rd quarter. After a promising drive stalled out for the Hayesmen, it was the defense and special teams that came up big. Stopping Pierre and bottling up this talented Crusader offense, and blocking the subsequent punt, giving the Cardinals the ball at the Stepinace 29 yard line. A big play from Simms to Felix Victorio matriculated the ball to the 5 yard line for Cardinal Hayes, where Kymonni Valentine finished the drive. He bulldozed into the endzone from 5 yards out with 17 second left in the 3rd quarter to give Cardinal Hayes a 16-10 lead. The Cardinal Hayes defense shut the door on the Crusaders on the next drive, sacking Wrona and bottling up Pierre. The offense would go on a grinding drive the next, running nearly 5 minutes off the clock before stalling out in the redzone. Stepinac would get the ball with 5 and half minutes left in the game down by 6 from their own 20 yard line. After driving to the Hayes 31 yard line, the Crusader offense could not convert on 4th down and the Hayesmen would earn a trip to New Rochelle to play #1 Iona Prep.
  • St. Anthony’s 42-Chaminade 27; Two teams that know each other very well. The Friars would host the Flyers yet again in a Long Island rivalry that has been revived this past decade. Where last meeting the Flyers would start off strong, shredding the Friar offense, it was clear from the beginning of this game this would be a different story. Forcing a 3 and out, the Friars would strike quickly. After a good punt return, Xavier Bala cruised into the endzone from 30 yards out on the first play from scrimmage. The Flyers did respond on their very next drive with Trapani doing most of the work on the ground and the air to tied the game up at 7 in the 1st quarter. But the Friars offense just has so many ways to attack. On the next drive Anthony Diieso found Luke Maurino for a 36 yard touchdown to take a 14-7 lead with 55 seconds left in the 1st quarter. Big plays from Bala and Diieso drove the ball down the field on the next drive after a Chaminade punt. Bala cruised in from 11 yards out to take a 21-7 lead with 7 minutes left in the 2nd quarter. A good drive was stymied by the Friars, and a blocked field goal kept the score at 21-7 going into the half. Bala would continue to put the hurt on the Flyers, exploding for a 29 yard touchdown run for his 3rd of the night to put the Friars up 28-7 early in the 3rd quarter. Sean Carnevale would respond, finding Christian Birch Trani for a touchdown pass on 4th down to cut the lead to 28-14. After forcing a St. Anthony’s punt, disaster struck for Chaminade. A turnover deep in Flyer territory resulted in Bala’s 4th touchdown of the game as they stretch the lead back to 21 at 35-14. Flyers would drive down the field on their next drive going into the 4th quarter. A key reception by Michael Genovese got the ball down to the Friar 1 yard line. Anthon Trapani powered it in from 1 yard out to cut the lead back to 14. Now less than 9 minutes to go, the defense just could not get a stop against this high powered Friar offense. After running Bala much of the next drive, draining the clock, Diieso would run in the nail in the coffin, from 13 yards out to put a cap on the evening. Up 42-21 with less than 4 minutes to go, the Flyers would drive down the field and score to make it 42-27 after Trapani’s 3rd touchdown run of the day. St. Anthony’s earned a date with #2 Monsignor Farrell next week a the Lion’s Den.

‘AA-I’

  • Kellenberg Memorial 23-St. Francis Prep 7; I am not sure the Firebirds expected to be challenged as much as they did in this game. While Kellenberg won this game by 14, this was a tight game going into the 4th quarter. The Firebirds clung to a 9-7 lead. The St. Francis Prep defense shutdown the Kellenberg offense for much of the 1st half, only allowing a score on a safety while backed up on their own goal line with 2:13 left in the 1st half. On the first drive of the second half, Kellenberg steadily drove the ball down the field. The drive including runs by Brendan Barkley, some quick passes to keep the chains moving and was capped by Doug Cristales for the Firebirds to go up 9-0 with 7:41 left in the 3rd quarter. After exchanging punts, the Terriers came alive. Taking the ball from their own 38 yard line, Brian Gleason hit Sal Vakili to get the ball to the 43 yard line of the Firebirds. Gleason would find Vakili for the next two plays, including a 36 yard touchdown to cut the lead to 9-7 with 1:49 left in the 3rd quarter. The Firebirds marched quickly on the ensuing possession, an early sign that the dam would begin to break for the Terriers. In the 4th quarter, Barkley converted a key 4th down to drive the ball to the 6 yard line. Cristales plunged into the endzone from 3 yards out to put the Firebirds up 16-7 with 11:27 left. After forcing a punt, Cristales ran the ball three times in a row, and broke a huge run to the 10 yard line. Quinn Saccheri would cap this drive with a 10 yard touchdown run with 6:54 left to put the game on ice. Kellenberg Memorial continues their fantastic season next week as they welcome #4 Fordham Prep to Uniondale for the semifinals.
  • St. Joseph by the Sea 35-St. John the Baptist 28; As is repeated on this page, it is a real shame that the Vikings could not find a way to stream their games. They are in the midst of a legendary season with now 3 what has been described as legendary games. All thanks to FB4 on Instagram for streaming the dramatic last few minutes of the game, but really this is a program that should have their games streamed and available. St. John the Baptist led most of this game. The Cougars held a usually productive running back Joseph Moran to just 68 yards on 16 carries. Pete Tronolone was held under 200 yards on 52% passing on the night, but it was the late game heroics, and offensive innovation that won them the day. Where nothing seemed to have gone right, the #2 seed of the ‘AA-I’ found themselves down 28-14 with 9:16 left. They were able to rattle off 3 straight touchdowns to win the game in overtime. Joseph Moran threw a touchdown– a 50 yarder to Arthur McCarthy, and while Moran couldn’t get anything going on the ground, he hauled in 9 passes for 129 yards and 3 touchdowns, including the equalizer and the game winner in overtime. Tronolone operated the offense, completing 13 of 25 passes for 174 yards, but perhaps more importantly, tossed 3 touchdowns and ran for another touchdown off 10 carries for 77 yards. The Vikings stay at home, and they play #4 Xaverian next— a part 2 to an instant classic from the regular season.
  • Xaverian 27-Xavier 21; Xaverian was reeling this past year, losing two important games late in the season to top ‘AA-I’ powers, and needed a strong win. While they got one last week against the Pilots, the Knights of Xavier would be a true test for the Clippers. It is November. At Aviator, a field they both share. The Clippers hadn’t beaten the Knights since 2014. And it would appear early on that would stay the case. The Clippers would go on a quick three and out on their first drive of the game only running 1:12 seconds off the clock. A good return would give the Knights the ball on their own 40 yard line with 10:48 left in the 1st quarter. Xaverian’s defense was tough. Stymying the single wing early on, but a pass play by Xavier behind the sticks for a key conversion, and some good runs got the ball inside the 10 yard line. Xavier pounded the interior of this Clipper defense. Marcello Vitale muscled his way into the endzone from 1 yard out to for the Knights to draw first blood. Xavier would go up 7-0, and ran 10 minutes and 43 seconds off the clock down to 1:05 left in the 1st quarter. Another quick 3 and out by the Clippers would hand the ball back to the the Knights at the Xaverian 41 yard line with 11:40 left in the 2nd quarter. This possession was quick. Anthony Pierro would do damage on the ground, with two big runs early on to set up his 24 yard touchdown run to give Xavier a 14-0 lead with 8:07 left in the half. Only having the ball for 6 plays for much of the 1st half, the Clippers would need to sustain a drive to get things going before things would get out of hand. Two straight hand offs to Richie Aiken would grant the Clippers their first 1st down of the game. This would be all the Clippers needed to get going. The frenetic pace of the Clippers would be on full display. After a few good runs by the offense, including a big one by Jake Price, Price himself would deliver a pass to score. He hit Christian LaRocca for a touchdown from 24 yards out to put the Clippers on the board 14-7 with 4:19 left in the 1st half. On the ensuing drive, Xavier would get the ball at their own 7 yard line after penalty nullified a good return. A big run by Marcello Vitale got the ball to their own 34 yard line. On the next play, a 66 yard run from Salvatore Vitale would put Xavier up 21-7 with 1:23 left in the 1st half. That was all the time the Clippers needed. A big pass play to Christian LaRocca set up a 21 yard touchdown run by Richie Aiken to cut the lead to 21-14 with 53 second left in the 1st half. This score would hold into the second half. On the fist possession of the second half, Xaverian would stuff the Knights on 4th and 2 on their own 35 yard line. Aiken would make them pay. He cruised into the endzone for a 13 yard touchdown run to tie up the game at 21-21 with 6:15 left in the 3rd quarter. Coach Aluotto rolled the dice, and called an onside kick. The Clippers recovered the onside kick, giving Xaverian an extra possession in great field position. The offense would take advantage, as Jake Price would find Bradley Spaeth in the endzone on 4th down for a 4 yard touchdown to put the Clippers up 27-21. Xaverian had effectively flipped the script on the Knights, dominated the time of possession in the 3rd quarter, and taking advantage of an extra possession. The game would go into the 4th quarter with the Clippers clinging to a 27-21 lead with the Knights having the ball. A key stop on 4th down with 4:55 left on the Clippers 20 yard line essentially put the nail in the coffin. A few first downs, and a big run by Richie Aiken where he slides on the 8 yard line to allow Xaverian to kneel the ball out and win the game. Xavier’s defense of their ‘AA-I’ championship ends here, but not their season. Xavier now has an extended time to get prepared for Fordham Prep for their annual Turkey Bowl game. Xaverian is now on the road. They head across the East River to play #2 St. Joseph by the Sea.
  • Fordham Prep 35-St. Peter’s 25; This is a different St. Peter’s team than the one that Fordham drubbed 41-21 earlier this season. Taking Sea to the brink, and beating Xavier last week had the Eagles confidence at an all time high, for good reason. The long road to Rose Hill on a rainy night in the Bronx with the Rose Hill Boys in full effect would prove to be a tough venue to play at. Both teams would drive a bit, but offenses would stall out and both teams would punt in a scoreless 1st quarter. St. Peter’s started the 2nd quarter on the Rams 37 yard line. A mix of pin point passes from Anthony D’Acunto, and tough running from him and Giancarlo Ciarmella would see the Eagles draw first blood in the 2nd quarter. A 1 yard touchdown run by Ciarmella with 9:21 left in the 2nd quarter put the Eagles up 7-0. Three straight completions on the next drive by quarterback Vincent DiPasquale for Fordham Prep to Adam Hermosura, Ryan McEvily and Luke McKay drove the ball about to the 5 yard line. A McKay 6 yard otuchdown run a play later tied the game at 7 with 8:17 left in the half. Some tough defense on both sides as the rain began to pour had the game go into the half tied at 7. To start the 2nd half DiPasquale found Chiesi for a 33 yard gain to start the game and get deep into STP territory. A big conversion on a pass to Hermosura got the ball to the STP 3 yard line, where McKay finished off the drive with a run to put them up ahead 14-7. A big punt return by Aaron Vazquez gave the ball to the Eagles at the FP 35 yard line. Two play later, Dylan Saladino would step in front of a pass and return the interception 82 yards for a touchdown to give the Rams a 21-7 lead with 2:52 left in the 3rd quarter. On the next Ram possession, after a punt backed them up, Giancarlo Ciaramella burst through the offensive line and dropped McKay in the endzone for a safety to cut the lead to 21-9. What could have been a huge swing for the Ealgles turned sour quick, as a snap went awry and the Rams pounced on it, getting the ball on their own 45 yard line. A completion from DiPasquale to Chiesi and a run by McKay advance the ball past midfield, setting up a pass to Brendan Campbell to get the ball to the 39 yard line. On the next play DiPasquale found Campbell streaking down the middle of the field for a 39 yard touchdown to open up a 28-9 lead with 9:37 to go. The Eagles would respond. On 3rd and long, D’Acunto would hit Aaron Vazquez for a 48 yard pass to set up a 1 yard touchdown run by D’Acunto with a 2 pt conversion on a pass to Xavier Boyd to cut the lead to 28-17. On a promising drive buoyed by a big run by McKay, the Rams would turn the ball over. Lorenzo Napoli would get the big interception to give the Eagles another chance near midfield. But the Rams defense came up big, with Rex Gilbert forcing a fumble on a quarterback scramble and Keith Ross jumping on it to end the scoring threat. Now with 5 and a half minutes left, the Rams needed to just keep the chains moving and the clock moving. A big play by Hermosura on a deep pass on 3rd down advanced the ball to the 26 yard line. McKay would ice the game with a 21 yard touchdown, his 3rd of the day, to put the Rams up 35-17 with 1:28 left. Chase Navarro would haul in a 28 yard touchdown with about a minute left. For the 3rd year in a row, and the first of Coach Seann Farrell’s tenure at the helm, the Rams head to the semifinal round, a rematch with #1 Kellenberg Memorial.

‘AA-II’

  • Kennedy Catholic 42-Cardinal Spellman 0; I cannot rewatch this game, as Kennedy Catholic locks their streams after they broadcast, but this was a statement by the Gaels. They are now on a roll– the Gales of Somers, led by Joseph DeSocio, Dominick Tassone, Jake Alves, and Austin Lanera, put the hurt on the Pilots. Kennedy Catholic has now won their last 4 games, and 5 of their last 6 games. In their victories, the Gaels have outscored their opponents 201-20. Their only loss in that span is their next opponent. A 33-6 loss in a downpour. The Gaels will face #2 Holy Cross next, and are looking for their revenge here.
  • St. Dominic 27-Christ the King 16; History was made in Oyster Bay Friday night. The Bayhawks, in their return the NYCHSFL, hosted, and won a playoff game. Their first in 51 years. Christ the King got the ball first in this game. They started off with a big run by Zion Gamble which drove the ball inside the Bayhawk 5 yard line. Ryan Risitano capped the quick drive off with a 3 yard touchdown. A 2 point conversion on a pass from Simon Valencia gave the Royals an 8-0 lead early in the 1st quarter. The Bayhawks would respond 2 drives later, forcing a Royal punt after their own drive stalled out deep in Christ the King territory. Minson would find Aaron Bengston open on a crossing route for a 20 yard touchdown to get on the board to cut the lead to 8-6. After a punt, Minson found Ford to pick up 6 yards. On 3rd down, Minson would find Nick Land deep down the field to flip the field and drive the ball to the 25 yard line of the Royals. But the Royals defense would strong and prevent the Bayhawks from cashing in. After forcing a Royals punt, Anthony Branscum took a toss 60 yards for a touchdown to put the Bayhawks up 12-8. Neither team would execute a 2 minute drill, and it would go into halftime with this score. St. Dominic would get the ball first in the 2nd half, and after a penalty, Minson would find Lang deep over the middle. A run by Paul Lawenson gave the ball to the Bayhawks on the 3 yard line. Minson would throw a pass to Michael Ford for a touchdown to put St. Dominic’s up 20-8 after a 2 point conversion. Christ the King responded though. Some big runs by Justin Brothers and Khari Carothers, and a big pass from Valencia to Brothers on 4th down for a 44 yard touchdown cut the lead to 20-16 after a 2 pt conversion. Big runs by Branscum set up an 18 yard touchdown to Bengston to put the Bayhawks back up by 11. The rest of the game had the Bayhawks grinding the clock away. The Royals took over with just over 3:33 left in the game but solid defense by St. Dominic secured the win. St. Dominic now goes on the road for a rematch against #1 Mount St. Michael.

Next week’s matchups:

Some of my takes:

For the ‘AAA’:

  • St. Anthony’s offense is still dangerous. I would not be surprised if if the gave Farrell a good game next week. Xavier Bala has also been playing defense, which has given that unit an immediate lift.
  • Cardinal Hayes needs to run the ball and keep Iona Prep offense off the field. The Hayes defense has the physicality and size to deal with the Gaels, but it is going to depend on the Hayesmen staying disciplined, mistake free, and executing their offense.

For the ‘AA-I’:

  • Kellenberg Memorial keeps plugging along. Taking care of business. They seemed to take a bit to wake up against St. Francis Prep, not something they can afford this week as the Rams come to town.
  • St. Joseph by the Sea now has had another brush with defeat. Can it be called a habit at this point? The Vikings are making their 3rd straight championship run, unprecedented in school history. They will need to take care of business.
  • Xaverian’s frenetic pace and explosiveness makes them a challenge for anyone. They don’t need much time to score. As much as this is an advantage for them, this is also an weakness. Can the Clippers thread the needle here against a championship caliber team this week?
  • Fordham Prep had some real balance this week. DiPasquale threw for 200 yards, and McKay had over 150 yards and 3 touchdowns. Their defense will have to be more disciplined this week as STP accumulated over 413 yards of offense.

For the ‘AA-II’

  • Kennedy Catholic has been impressive, but their opponents have left a lot to be desired. They have beaten Cardinal Spellman twice, Christ the King, Nazareth, and St. Dominic’s. The game they have coming up against Holy Cross is going to be huge for the Gaels. Can they get up against a team aiming for a championship? We shall see.
  • St. Dominic’s made history, but they face a juggernauts in Mount St. Michael. They will need to pay a lot better against the Mount to have a chance. The Bayhawks were only up 20-16 late in the game against Christ the King.

It is important to acknowledge, and have a moment of silence for team’s seasons who have ended.

Archbishop Stepinac– I felt the Crusaders were better this year than they were last year. But the buzzsaw of a schedule they had did not help them. At 5-6. AJ Magee is now 12-12 over his first two seasons. This is not what the Stepinac faithful, especially in recent times, are used to, and more will be demanded of them next season. This is an important offseason for the Crusaders.

Chaminade- The Flyers end their season 3-8. After two good years, Chaminade’s program takes a noticeable step back. I think that a lot of the issues I see with Chaminade were made much more apparent this year. There is a real lack of explosiveness on offense. The defense can’t keep up with the best teams in this league. Now high school football is cyclical, but I do think Chaminade will need to do something a bit different if they want to challenge the top of the ‘AAA’ again.

St. Peter’s- High expectations in the offseason were quickly derailed by key transfers and injuries early on. This was a difficult year for St. Peter’s as they went 2-9. The Eagles showed real fight down the stretch, but the challenges were just too much as the season wore on. This is a program that is smaller, so the challenges and the margins are tighter when it comes to being a competitive team. Coach Giannatasio and DeCristoforo do have a decent foundation with a JV team. With Monsignor Farrell dominating the island as of late, the Eagles will need to have a good offseason to come back to competing for ‘AA-I’ championships.

St. John the Baptist- What could have been. Injuries derailed the already thin program. The Cougars went 3-6 this year with some disappointing losses down the stretch. This is a program that won a championship at the ‘AA-I’ level not long ago, so the Cougars do have the ability to compete.

St. Francis Prep- The Terriers were senior laden last year, so a noticeable drop off was to be expected from them. They went 2-8 this season, and I do think the football program at St. Francis Prep needs to do some soul searching. Their wing T offense, and the way they used their best players needs to be re-examined. The Wing T in this age just is not an offense you can run and expect to have success. The program needs to examine themselves to figure what happens when their JV team turns the page into a Varsity squad. Terrier JV teams are very good, and there is drop off when they join the varsity. This is a school that can support some of the best football in New York since they have over 2,400 kids at the school. Who knows.

Cardinal Spellman- Year 2 for Coach Burnett, and the Pilots ended their year 2-8. Essentially the same record as last season. The team is big enough, with an impressive 50 players on the team, but this is still very much a program that is in development. It will be up to Coach Burnett and his staff to stay with it and will be up to the school itself to support it.

Christ the King– A plethora of transfers and a coaching change did not set this team up for success, but I feel like even if those folks stayed, it would have been a tough year. The team was just so young, and they went 2-7. But the general youth of the team is something the school can market and invest in. Christ the King is always a draw for press when the football team is good, and they have a youthful foundation to build on with a lot of younger kids. The administration there has an opportunity but this offseason is key.

Nazareth Regional- I did not get to Nazareth last week, but their season is over. At 0-6, the revival of the Kingsmen has had some challenges. It is important to understand though that the NYCHSFL is a very competitive league, and like Christ the King, Nazareth had a lot of underclassmen playing varsity football. This comes with a lot of challenges.

What thoughts, and comments do you have?

4 responses to “Pete’s Take on 2026 NYCHSFL Quarterfinals”

  1. John Slocum Avatar
    John Slocum

    has any other school in the nychsfl ever finished the regular season undefeated at all three levels?

    1. pete1841 Avatar

      Would have to be St. Anthony’s program in the 2000s. All three levels would usually win out during their heyday.

    2. John Slocum Avatar
      John Slocum

      no question they would have finished in first during those amazing years but didn’t know if all three levels sustained no losses along the way.

      1. pete1841 Avatar

        I dont really ever remember any level of St Anthony’s losing when I was in HS.

Leave a Reply

Designed with WordPress