It is now August! It has unfortunately been a busy two offseasons for the NYCHSFL over the past two years. The folding of Moore Catholic High School, and Holy Trinity Diocesan High School football programs have left a hole in the league.
The league boasted 23 programs, after re-admitting Nazareth Regional, and St. Dominic’s High School back. Now, just two years later, We is back down to 21. Worse yet, aside from these two communities losing their football program, the folding of these programs so late in the offseason has really messed up the league schedule. There is just no time to adjust, and teams had to take a BYE, standings, and power points are messed up. With 7 teams only playing 6 league games, the formula to determine points can be seen as unfair.
What is troubling to me is the circumstances around the closure of these programs. While they both followed similar timelines, the situations were quite different.
To summarize, Moore Catholic’s coach, Nick Giannatasio, abruptly left in the winter and was immediately hired at St. Peter’s Boys High School. This was after Moore Catholic had gone to three straight ‘AA-1’ Championship games, but had a disappointing year in 2024 with an early exit in the playoffs. See my take on Moore Catholic football folding here.
Holy Trinity’s closure, though it follows a similar timeline, really highlights the administrative incompetence at the Diocesan school, and really just seems like it is malicious incompetence. I do not believe Holy Trinity ever intended to have football in 2026. See the whole series of events of Holy Trinity Football folding here.
Due to league rules, suspended football programs have a 5 year waiting period before they can apply to be admitted into the NYCHSFL again. This means Moore Catholic is gone until at least 2030, and Holy Trinity gone until at least 2031.
From my perspective, the NYCHSFL should try to make overtures to other Catholic or private programs to bolster their ranks. In previous posts, I have made direct suggestions at adding three upstate Catholic schools to the league. With pressure from the NYSPHSAA Sections 1, 2, and 3, to eliminate private schools from their leagues, there is going to be a demand for both the NYCHSFL and MMHSAA to expand and incorporate these teams. See news stories below:
To summarize, Section 1 (Westchester/Rockland County) has voted to remove private schools from Sectional playoffs, essentially making regular seasons meaningless for private schools. Section 2 has done a similar thing. Section 3, most of the programs have refused to play the Christian Brothers Academy of Syracuse in football, forcing the Brothers to fill their schedule with nonleague games.
While the fights in Sections 1 and 2 are still ongoing, with the appeals board overturning the vote just late last month, it appears that this movement has momentum. Mark my words, public schools will succeed in removing private schools from their ranks, they have the will and support of their constituents. From my perspective, it is better to plan for the inevitable than idly wait for this to happen.
The trend towards eliminating private schools from the NYSPHSAA may necessitate the collaboration of private schools across the state. I posted back in the winter on the state of high school football in New York, and I won’t rehash the details. But due to recent news, especially regarding Christian Brothers Academy in Syracuse and the situation in Sections 1 and 2, may push Catholic schools to give up football, or consolidate and join the MMHSAA/CHSAA/NYCHSFL.
To go on a tangent, Christian Brothers Academy of Syracuse (Section 3) is essentially playing a MMHSAA schedule this year, see below:

Below is a map of the current MMHSAA programs, and a map of the Catholic Schools currently competing in the NYSPHSAA:
Could something not be worked out to make or expand a league? I admit the logistics sound awfully daunting, but with the prospect of being forced to be in a position where you have no options, why not collaborate?
Below is a map of an ideal MMHSAA for football
There are three Catholic Schools in the Archdiocese of New York that compete in the NYSPHSAA. The schools are:
- Albertus Magnus High School in Rockland Country (just over the Cuomo/Tappan Zee Bridge)
- John S. Burke Catholic High School about an hour west of Kennedy Catholic in Orange County
- Our Lady of Lourdes High School are about an hour north of Kennedy Catholic High School in Dutchess County
I used Kennedy Catholic High School because it is the furthest north that the NYCHSFL currently stretches.
Below is a map of the current NYCHSFL, and a map of the NYCHSFL including the above programs:
- Map of the NYCHSFL (counting Holy Trinity and Moore Catholic)
- Ideal Map of the NYCHSFL
I feel this should be the goal, of course, this would be if, and only if, the NYCHSFL was able to re-admit Moore and Trinity, and if there won’t be any more issues with other programs.
On the other side, the other program I would seriously look at is Long Island Lutheran High School. Though they are Protestant, and their membership in the Catholic League would be ironic, I do think solidifying Long Island with 6 programs is important for the integrity of the league. I am unsure if their non-Catholic status is a disqualifier though. It probably is, right?
Of course, the added travel times, especially for teams in the ‘AA-2’ and ‘AA-1’ in Downstate New York, particularly, Queens, Staten Island, Brooklyn, and Long Island, would make travel difficult. With such a geographic spread, I do think the NYCHFSL should begin talks with the Metropolitan Independent Football League. The MIFL is a league that spreads throughout the tri-state, including New York City, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Westchester. The schools are:
- Riverdale Country School (Bronx, NY)
- The Pingry School (Basking Ridge, NJ)
- Poly Prep Country Day School (Brooklyn, NY)
- Rye Country Day School (Rye, NY)
- Hackley School (Tarrytown, NY)
- Morristown-Beard School (Morristown, NJ)
- Horace Mann School (Bronx, NY)
- Hopkins School (New Haven, CT)
- Ethical Culture Fieldston School (Bronx, NY)
- Montclair Kimberley Academy (Montclair, NJ)
- The Dalton School (New York, NY)
- Newark Academy (Livingston, NJ)
- King School (Stamford, CT)
Map of MIFL+Long Island Lutheran
While the style of football is unmistakably different (the MIFL does not have kickoffs), the NYCHSFL and MIFL joining forces would make scheduling much easier, especially for smaller schools. Hackley, and Poly Prep have already played NYCHSFL foes pretty consistently over the years, so there are some relationships with those schools.
I am unsure of what structure this agreement would have, but I do think there is space for more collaboration between the private school football leagues.
We’ll just have to see.
What do you think of the State of the League? Leave your thoughts below, or DM me.


Leave a Reply