It’s August, and summer vacation has long ended for football players. As teams have returned to work, let’s take a look at how last season ended.

In the ‘AAA’ division, Iona Prep won the championship game 43-22 against St. Anthony’s at Mitchel Field in Uniondale, NY. They won the CHSAA State Championship 42-26 against Canisius HS in Buffalo, NY, finishing with a record of 11-2. St. Joseph by the Sea won their first  ‘AA-1’ against fellow Staten Island school St Peter’s, with the championship game at the Lion’s Den, 8-7, capping off a 11-2 campaign, winning their last 7 games. Xaverian finished with a 6-6 record, winning the ‘AA-2’ division against Holy Cross 14-6 on a windy morning at Mitchel Field after losing in the ‘AA-2’ championship to Mount in 2023.

Wrapping up the Thanksgiving day games, Xavier shut out the Fordham Prep Rams at Aviator field 28-0 in a windy and rainy game for their first win in their series since 2019. Cardinal Hayes shut out Mount 22-0 for their 11th straight win in their series. 

As the CHSFL goes into the new season, the divisions have realigned. The ‘AAA’ shrunk to six teams. Kellenberg has moved down to the ‘AA-1’. Holy Trinity has moved down to the ‘AA-2’ after a 1-10 season, The ‘AA-2’ has also added two more schools, St. Dominic’s HS as a full time member, and Nazareth Regional High School. Unfortunately, due to administration and coaching disputes, the former Moore Catholic coach, Nick Giannatasio, and Moore parted ways, only for Nick to join St. Peter’s Boys HS to become the third triumvirate. This resulted in the Moore Catholic football program folding, made official last month. Since it’s too late to change the schedule, Moore Catholic will forfeit their games this season. Knowing what I know about power points, an 0-7 Moore Catholic team does not award any points to their opponents, but it automatically makes games against those teams worth more, since they have an automatic win.

This makes a 6 team ‘AAA’, an 7 team ‘AA-1’, and a 9 team ‘AA-2’.

2025 NYCHSFL Preseason rankings below:

‘AAA’

  1. Iona Prep
  2. St. Anthony’s
  3. Cardinal Hayes
  4. Archbishop Stepinac
  5. Chaminade
  6. Monsignor Farrell

‘AA-1’

  1. Kellenberg
  2. St. Joseph by the Sea
  3. St. Peter’s
  4. Moore Catholic (folded)
  5. Fordham Prep
  6. Xavier
  7. St. Francis Prep
  8. St. John the Baptist

‘AA-2’

  1. Xaverian
  2. Holy Trinity
  3. Holy Cross
  4. Mount St. Michael
  5. Christ the King
  6. Cardinal Spellman
  7. Kennedy Catholic
  8. St. Dominic
  9. Nazareth

My thoughts on these rankings:

Now with only 6 teams in the ‘AAA’, it appears that the gap between ‘AAA’ and ‘AA-1’ teams has gotten wider. The ‘AAA’ has now gone from the 12 team division it was in the mid 2010s, to just a handful of teams. As the teams in the top league dwindle, more Catholics, and people in general, will likely only pay attention to the leagues that matter to them personally. Because 16 of the 23 teams in the CHSFL are in the ‘AA-1’ or ‘AA-2’, there is just more content to write about at these levels. It’s just more interesting and competitive.

In the past, teams played for something in the regular season. In a 12 team ‘AAA’, the bottom four ‘AAA’ programs moved down to compete in the ‘AA-1’ playoffs, and the bottom teams of the ‘AA-1’ would compete in the ‘AA-2’ (back then just ‘A’) playoffs. I have found the regular season boring in recent seasons, since there are no stakes, everyone makes their division playoffs anyway, and it’s not like there aren’t crossover games. #2 St. Anthony’s plays #11 Fordham Prep this year, #1 Iona Prep plays 2 ‘AA-1’ teams (#8 St. Joe’s by the Sea, and #7 Kellenberg) this year. If I were the CHSFL, I would personally really consider going back to this formula, so you have teams battling for playoff spots.

As for the actual rankings, after a long summer, here are my preseason thoughts.

In the ‘AAA’:

  • I scratch my head at putting Farrell at #6, and Stepinac at #4. I feel like they should be switched. The Crusaders had a 1-10 season in 2024, and now have a new head coach. Prove that last season was a fluke and earn a higher ranking.
  • Chaminade at #5 sounds about right, they lost a lot of talent, but so did the rest of the ‘AAA’. The only team on the ‘AAA’ level that seems to have gotten stronger on paper is Iona. 

In the ‘AA-1’:  

  • Two of the Staten Island teams are in the top 4. I just don’t see it. Peter’s lost their engines on offense, they should be lower.
  • Personally, I would put have put Fordham Prep, and Xavier at the #3 and #4 spot and moved Peter’s down to #5. 
  • St. Francis Prep also had a good season, albeit against ‘AA-2’ foes. They get no breaks this year. But their spot is good for them now. The program just has not been strong for a while, so it makes sense that they be #13. 
  • St. John the Baptist is where they should be. They were 2-8 last season. The ‘AA-1’ is as unpredictable this season as it was last year. I expect a lot of movement during the year, and a lot of surprises during the course of the season. 
  • Unfortunately, I don’t think it matters at the end of the day. Kellenberg is clearly the strongest team in the ‘AA-1’.

In the ‘AA-2’:

  • They moved Holy Trinity to the ‘AA-2’ after a disastrous 1-10 season in 2024. I would think they would be the favorite this year, but they are ranked #2, behind champion Xaverian. 
  • The ‘AA-2 is really a four horse race, with Mount, Holy Cross, Holy Trinity, and Xaverian in the top four. They were the only teams with JV squads last season. It is difficult to judge how good the rest of the division will be. 
  • Of the remaining programs, Cardinal Spellman at #6, and Kennedy Catholic at #7 are teams I would watch here. 
  • Christ the King’s coaching staff has come aboard with much fanfare, then was fired. It is unclear what exactly happened. Still, CTK has a JV squad this year. Is this why they are ranked #5 in the ‘AA-2’? Christ the King’s 2024 and 2023 was disastrous. 
  • St. Dominic and Nazareth both rejoin the CHSFL, and will go through a seven game schedule. Grueling for these schools which have just over 300 students. I applaud them coming back, and I look forward to covering them.

Now, I know it is early, but with the playoff bracket is going to look different this year:

  • The ‘AAA’ will be playing a standard 6 team bracket, where the top 2 seeds get a first round bye.
  • With 7 competing in the ‘AA-1’, the playoffs for the ‘AA-1’ will be a standard 7 team bracket– with the number 1 seed earning a bye.
  • With 9 teams in the ‘AA-2’, the top 8 teams of the ‘AA-2’ will make the playoff, and the playoffs will be a standard 8 team bracket.

What do you think about this upcoming season? What are you most looking forward to? What unexpected, dark horse teams will make noise? I look forward to seeing how it all works out, and coming back to this post next year when I write the 2025 season review.

Next up, Week 0!

One response to “August 2025; 2024 Season Review and 2025 Pre-Season Rankings”

  1. […] We are two weeks away from the opening of camp! Summer is coming to an end, and we have officially hit the home stretch before camp opens, and games start being played. With the official start date for most NYCHSFL schools will be August 17 and games happening just two weeks later for week 0, I think it is valuable to go over where the league was in November 2025, and where the league sits today, similar to what I did last August. […]

Leave a Reply

Designed with WordPress