Just be forewarned, this is a true offseason post. I am not even sure what the purpose of this post is or what point I am trying to make. I think I just find the landscape of the area interesting, how the schools operate, the dynamics of each area and division, and how that shapes the league today. There is also a lot of good information out there that isn’t really compiled into one spot. The amount of time, research, and scouring of the internet I had to do for this piece is more than I would like to admit. 

The landscape of the competitiveness of High School football is linked very closely with the options, and resources that each program has to work with, and how that relates to local public school districts. Schools with a lot of resources, often (not always) do better than those with not a lot of resources. The PSAL shares territory in New York City, the Long Island Sections VIII and XI share geographic territory with the Long Island Schools, and Section I shares geographic territory with the Westchester schools of the CHSFL. The Upstate counterpart to the CHSFL, the MMHSAA, is in Section II. Direct competition of these public school districts plays directly into the enrollment, and the success of the Catholic Schools of the CHSFL. At least in Westchester and Long Island, many of the local school districts are just as good, if not better than the private Catholic schools in the area. A common talking point when discussing education options is centered on why would you, after paying exorbitant property taxes (whether you own, or rent), and then turn around and pay tuition to send your child to a Catholic school? And it is a good question but not one for this post, or this account. 

While a Catholic education is preferable for the many Catholics and Christians in the Archdiocese of New York, Diocese of Brooklyn, and Rockville Center, the realities of the current world can often make tuition, and the additional costs of sending children to private Catholic school unattainable. While most of these schools have scholarship or financial aid programs, these are theoretically supposed to be reserved for those who qualify academically. 

When talking about the CHSFL, it is important to know how the Catholic Church divides up territory. The Catholic world is split into dioceses. A group of dioceses surrounded by an Archdiocese is an Ecclesiastical Province. Anyways, for the purposes of the CHSFL there are three dioceses that make up where the schools are, and it is these organizations that support most of the Catholic schools. Here, we are part of the Ecclesiastical Province of New York, which is then in turn split into dioceses. The three Diocese are that NYCHSFL operates in are:

  • The Archdiocese of New York: Encompasses, Staten Island, Manhattan, the Bronx, Westchester, Rockland, Putnam, Dutchess, Orange, and Ulster Counties. 
  • The Diocese of Brooklyn: Encompasses Brooklyn and Queens
  • The Diocese of Rockville Center: Encompasses Nassau and Suffolk Counties

In my short time of running this blog, the proliferation of players transferring schools seems to be bleeding into the High School landscape, as it has become pervasive in college athletics. This concerns me. I see a disturbing trend on social media, where 8th graders, yes, 8th graders are posting their “commitments” to play sports at an academic institution. Students in the middle of their high school athletic career are transferring to certain schools, often commuting across county, and state lines, oftentimes over an hour each way. 

I am very much an outsider on these topics, so I do have some questions I would like to pose. 

  • What are the rules around athletic recruiting?
  • Are these rules, if they exist, followed? What are the enforcement mechanisms for these rules?
  • If there are no rules, is this right?
  • How pervasive is this?

As for the average family who has a child who just wants to play football, which is most kids on these teams, and isn’t into this landscape, I think it is important to present which schools charge the most tuition, and which schools are the most successful (I think everyone wants to be on a good team). Which schools are diocesan(as in they receive support from their diocese)? What are you, or your family, paying for? 

Football is easily the most expensive sport, as it has many players, expensive equipment, requires a field, a robust coaching staff, buses to away games, etc. To say the football fee pays for it all, is naive. At the end of the day, these are academic institutions, and it is important to understand the dynamic that your school has with its football program. For schools with thousands of students, football isn’t too much of a burden in cost, as it is spread across more families, but for smaller ones? The football program is a huge cost of their athletic department. If your school is co-ed, the families that send girls to the school are subsidizing the football team, even though there is little chance that their child would be part of the program.

It is important to see how your program is funded, and if your team is subsidized by parishioners of the local parish, or subsidized by every practicing Catholic in your diocese. Independent schools, ones not associated with a diocese, have a lot more flexibility in how they operate, and how they support their athletic program. They are often sponsored, or straight up run by Religious orders, and often will have higher tuition costs than diocesan school. The trade off here is that without being sponsored by the diocese, the schools can be forced to charge more, since they are not getting the subsidy from the Church. These high tuition costs are part of the reason why you have students that transfer in and out every year. 

I have, below, the tuition, enrollment, and whether your school is independent or not listed below, sorted by division:

‘AAA’

  1. Iona Prep;~1,000 boys; $20,600; Independent (Congregation of the Christian Brothers)
  2. St. Anthony’s;~2,400 students; $12,950; Independent (Franciscan Brothers)
  3. Cardinal Hayes;~750 boys; $8,100; New York Archdiocesan School
  4. Archbishop Stepinac; ~775 boys; $16,950; New York Archdiocesan School 
  5. Chaminade, ~1,700 boys; $17,300; Independent (Marianist)
  6. Monsignor Farrell, ~815 boys; $11,800; New York Archdiocesan School 

‘AA-1’

  1. Kellenberg Memorial; ~2,550 students; $14,000; Independent (Marianist)
  2. St. Joseph by the Sea; ~1,200 students; $9,480; New York Archdiocesan School 
  3. St. Peter’s; ~450 boys; $9,175; Independent (De La Salle Brothers)
  4. Moore Catholic;~425 students; $9,000; New York Archdiocesan School 
  5. Fordham Prep; ~950 boys; $24,610; Independent (Jesuits)
  6. Xavier; ~975 boys; $25,250; Independent (Jesuits)
  7. St. Francis Prep; ~2465 students; $10,600; Independent (Franciscan Brothers)
  8. St. John the Baptist; ~1,200 students; $14,200; Rockville Center Diocesan School

‘AA-2’

  1. Xaverian; ~1,625 students; $18,100; Independent (Xaverian Brothers)
  2. Holy Trinity; ~800 students; $14,250; Rockville Center Diocesan School
  3. Holy Cross, ~700 students; $11,050; Independent (Congregation of Holy Cross)
  4. Mount Saint Michael; ~700 boys; $10,100; Independent (Marist Brothers)
  5. Christ the King Regional; ~665 students; $11,950; Brooklyn Diocesan School
  6. Cardinal Spellman; ~1,120 students; $10,900; New York Archdiocesan School 
  7. Kennedy Catholic; ~680 students; $10,400; New York Archdiocesan School 
  8. St. Dominic’s; ~335 students; $14,250; Rockville Center Diocesan School (St. Dominic’s Parish)
  9. Nazareth Regional; ~315 students;  $8,575; Independent (Xaverian Brothers)

I don’t see a relationship between the size of the school, the tuition, and success of each program in the CHSFL. A few thoughts:

  • The sheer size of St. Anthony’s, St. Francis Prep, Chaminade and Kellenberg are particularly jarring to me. The inconsistency of these football programs has me scratching my head. Two of the four largest schools are in the ‘AA-1’
  • The two Jesuit schools, Fordham Prep and Xavier, having large student populations, and highest tuitions in the CHSFL tells me that these just are not football schools. Both of these schools pride themselves in academics. With tuition over $24,000, I can’t see how these schools are affordable. Being in the ‘AA-1’ makes sense to me, considering the size of their programs, but a price tag like that will likely lock out a lot of folks from considering these schools
  • Iona Prep being #3 in tuition does track. Seeing tuition over $20,000 is just absolutely crazy to me. They must give people scholarships, and tons of financial aid. They are without a doubt the strongest program in the entire league.
  • Stepinac is a diocesan school, and their tuition is ~$7,000 more than their peer diocesan schools (Hayes, Spellman, Kennedy, Sea, Moore, and Farrell). This has to be by choice. 
  • Moore Catholic, with only 425 students, coed at the ‘AA-1’ level is amazing to me. Just really an inconceivable achievement.  St. Peter’s is small as well, though they are boys only. 
  • Xaverian should run the ‘AA-2’. Their school is just too big, and their tuition is very high. They should have the resources to go into the ‘AA-1’. Perhaps soon. 
  • A trend I have noticed:
    • 5 of the 6 ‘AAA’ schools are boys only
    • 5 of the 8 ‘AA-1’ schools are co-ed
    • 8 of the 9 ‘AA-2’ schools are co-ed. 
    • Not sure what this means, but it’s just something I noticed. 
  • Broken down by diocese:
    •  The Diocese of Rockville Center on Long Island, does not seem to support their schools as much, as their tuitions are quite a bit higher than their independent counterparts. 
    • The Diocese of Brooklyn does not really have diocesan schools, only Christ the King, and they are a smaller school. The tuitions here are varied, though I know that these schools often are threatened the most when it comes to closure. 
    • The Archdiocese of New York, which is the largest of the three, seems to support their schools enough to keep tuitions at around $8,000-$11,000. This in turn, should keep the rest of the regions independent schools’ price tag reasonable, but I am not sure how much this helped. Three of the most expensive schools in the CHSFL are in the Archdiocese of New York. 

This is a peak offseason post, and I am not even sure what the purpose of this piece is, but I think this is a lot of interesting information about the character of the schools that compete in the CHSFL, and it helps us better understand the storylines going forward. 

Leave a Reply

Designed with WordPress